Type Savoring: Readability
This page displays
an article, repeated four times. This has been done using 4 different
fonts, two SERIF and two SANS SERIF. Can you feel a difference in readability?
(The article, quoted
from The
Encyclopedia of Typography and Electronic Communications,
is worth reading at least one of the times. 8-)
Read it in TIMES (serif)
Read it in COURIER NEW (serif)
Read it in ARIAL (sans serif)
Read it in MS SANS SERIF
- First sample:
TIMES, a serif font.
back to top
- The process whereby a typeface is viewed
and its visual characteristics and impact have an effect on, and are
evaluated by, a person. A more scientific name for this may be «typeface
psychology.» The end purpose of type savoring is not the classification
of a typeface, but, rather, an appraisal of its aesthetic attributes
(primary) and emotional impact (secondary). Type savoring may often
be a lengthly and complex process. It is certainly a very poorly-understood,
rarely studied, and little-discussed aspect of typography. There may
be an extensive set of underlying scientific principles governing type
savoring.
Type savoring may reach completion
or fruition only after a period of time and a number of viewings.
The process usually proceeds in a number of phases.
Initial Viewing - Phase 1
The eye and brain evaluates a design for basic stand-alone (macroscopic)
characteristics: type color, ornamentation, stroke contrast, letterform
proportion, letterform design consistency, and possibly other characteristics.
Sometimes, if any of these characteristics are notable, emotional
impact is generated.
Recognition - Phase 2
The eye and brain focus on the individual letterforms, and attempt
to relate their shape (microscopic) characteristics to similar letterforms
(of another typeface perception or mental image). Subliminal impact
of letterform design makes its mark at this stage.
Bargaining - Phase 3
The eye and brain, having evaluated the typeface design both macroscopically
and microscopically, go through an appraisal phase, intermediate between
recognition and comprehension. This could also be termed an « acceptance/
rejection » phase, where the brain, having made comparisons to other
perceived typefaces, attempts to decide (letterform by letterform,
word by word, and overall) whether the design is good or bad, pleasant
or unpleasant, acceptable or unacceptable. This is termed a « bargaining
» phase, because the brain may be performing a trade-off study between
acceptable and rejectable design points. It should be noted that subliminal
and emotional impact is not generated during this phase, but rather
this phase is driven by subliminal and emotional impact uncovered
or generated in previous phases.
Comprehension - Phase 4
The eye and brain then parses the text. If the purpose of the viewing
is type savoring, then this process is merely another test. If a typeface
design presents difficulties in comprehension performance, this is
detected in this phase.
Aftereffects - Phase 5
During or after comprehension, perception and impressions form, stemming
from viewing the typeface design. These impressions may include more
of the subliminal or emotional impact uncovered in previous phases,
along with new impressions. These new impressions may take the form
of subliminal or emotional impact, or concepts, characterized by words
like: attitude, prim, elegance, mechanical, happy, joyful, sad, adamant,
permissive, peculiar, etc.
Retention - Phase 6
This phase relates to the information the brain remembers about the
typeface after the viewing concludes—its last impressions. The information
may consist of all or part of what was discovered or uncovered in
previous phases; or it may actually be innacurate or erroneous impressions.
This phase is crucial if the typeface is to be selected again (say,
for design) based on memory alone.
Subsequent Repeated Viewing
If a familiar typeface is viewed again, phase 1 does not occur. In
fact, the brain my jump to phase 2, then phase 4. It may occasionally
go through phase 5, reinforcing or modifying its experiences, but
it probably never skips phase 6.
It is interesting to observe that once
a person develops an opinion on a particular typeface, the opinion
very often never changes. What is also interesting is that the subliminal
impact of a typeface never changes, and is very often the same for
many people, whether or not their opinion on a particular typeface
design is favorable or not. This is why typeface design and selection
is such a compelling factor in advertising design.
-
back to top
- Second sample: COURIER NEW, a serif font.
back to top
- The process whereby a typeface is viewed and its visual characteristics
and impact have an effect on, and are evaluated by, a person. A more
scientific name for this may be «typeface psychology.» The
end purpose of type savoring is not the classification of a typeface,
but, rather, an appraisal of its aesthetic attributes (primary) and
emotional impact (secondary). Type savoring may often be a lengthly
and complex process. It is certainly a very poorly-understood, rarely
studied, and little-discussed aspect of typography. There may be an
extensive set of underlying scientific principles governing type savoring.
Type savoring may reach completion or fruition only after a period
of time and a number of viewings. The process usually proceeds in
a number of phases.
Initial Viewing - Phase 1
The eye and brain evaluates a design for basic stand-alone (macroscopic)
characteristics: type color, ornamentation, stroke contrast, letterform
proportion, letterform design consistency, and possibly other characteristics.
Sometimes, if any of these characteristics are notable, emotional
impact is generated.
Recognition - Phase 2
The eye and brain focus on the individual letterforms, and attempt
to relate their shape (microscopic) characteristics to similar letterforms
(of another typeface perception or mental image). Subliminal impact
of letterform design makes its mark at this stage.
Bargaining - Phase 3
The eye and brain, having evaluated the typeface design both macroscopically
and microscopically, go through an appraisal phase, intermediate between
recognition and comprehension. This could also be termed an « acceptance/
rejection » phase, where the brain, having made comparisons to other
perceived typefaces, attempts to decide (letterform by letterform,
word by word, and overall) whether the design is good or bad, pleasant
or unpleasant, acceptable or unacceptable. This is termed a « bargaining
» phase, because the brain may be performing a trade-off study between
acceptable and rejectable design points. It should be noted that subliminal
and emotional impact is not generated during this phase, but rather
this phase is driven by subliminal and emotional impact uncovered
or generated in previous phases.
Comprehension - Phase 4
The eye and brain then parses the text. If the purpose of the viewing
is type savoring, then this process is merely another test. If a typeface
design presents difficulties in comprehension performance, this is
detected in this phase.
Aftereffects - Phase 5
During or after comprehension, perception and impressions form, stemming
from viewing the typeface design. These impressions may include more
of the subliminal or emotional impact uncovered in previous phases,
along with new impressions. These new impressions may take the form
of subliminal or emotional impact, or concepts, characterized by words
like: attitude, prim, elegance, mechanical, happy, joyful, sad, adamant,
permissive, peculiar, etc.
Retention - Phase 6
This phase relates to the information the brain remembers about the
typeface after the viewing concludes—its last impressions. The information
may consist of all or part of what was discovered or uncovered in
previous phases; or it may actually be innacurate or erroneous impressions.
This phase is crucial if the typeface is to be selected again (say,
for design) based on memory alone.
Subsequent Repeated Viewing
If a familiar typeface is viewed again, phase 1 does not occur. In
fact, the brain my jump to phase 2, then phase 4. It may occasionally
go through phase 5, reinforcing or modifying its experiences, but
it probably never skips phase 6.
It is interesting to observe that once a person develops an opinion
on a particular typeface, the opinion very often never changes. What
is also interesting is that the subliminal impact of a typeface never
changes, and is very often the same for many people, whether or not
their opinion on a particular typeface design is favorable or not.
This is why typeface design and selection is such a compelling factor
in advertising design.
-
back to top
- Third sample: ARIAL, a sans-serif font.
back to top
- The process whereby a typeface is viewed and its visual characteristics
and impact have an effect on, and are evaluated by, a person. A more
scientific name for this may be «typeface psychology.» The
end purpose of type savoring is not the classification of a typeface,
but, rather, an appraisal of its aesthetic attributes (primary) and
emotional impact (secondary). Type savoring may often be a lengthly
and complex process. It is certainly a very poorly-understood, rarely
studied, and little-discussed aspect of typography. There may be an
extensive set of underlying scientific principles governing type savoring.
Type savoring may reach completion or fruition only after a period
of time and a number of viewings. The process usually proceeds in
a number of phases.
Initial Viewing - Phase 1
The eye and brain evaluates a design for basic stand-alone (macroscopic)
characteristics: type color, ornamentation, stroke contrast, letterform
proportion, letterform design consistency, and possibly other characteristics.
Sometimes, if any of these characteristics are notable, emotional
impact is generated.
Recognition - Phase 2
The eye and brain focus on the individual letterforms, and attempt
to relate their shape (microscopic) characteristics to similar letterforms
(of another typeface perception or mental image). Subliminal impact
of letterform design makes its mark at this stage.
Bargaining - Phase 3
The eye and brain, having evaluated the typeface design both macroscopically
and microscopically, go through an appraisal phase, intermediate between
recognition and comprehension. This could also be termed an « acceptance/
rejection » phase, where the brain, having made comparisons to other
perceived typefaces, attempts to decide (letterform by letterform,
word by word, and overall) whether the design is good or bad, pleasant
or unpleasant, acceptable or unacceptable. This is termed a « bargaining
» phase, because the brain may be performing a trade-off study between
acceptable and rejectable design points. It should be noted that subliminal
and emotional impact is not generated during this phase, but rather
this phase is driven by subliminal and emotional impact uncovered
or generated in previous phases.
Comprehension - Phase 4
The eye and brain then parses the text. If the purpose of the viewing
is type savoring, then this process is merely another test. If a typeface
design presents difficulties in comprehension performance, this is
detected in this phase.
Aftereffects - Phase 5
During or after comprehension, perception and impressions form, stemming
from viewing the typeface design. These impressions may include more
of the subliminal or emotional impact uncovered in previous phases,
along with new impressions. These new impressions may take the form
of subliminal or emotional impact, or concepts, characterized by words
like: attitude, prim, elegance, mechanical, happy, joyful, sad, adamant,
permissive, peculiar, etc.
Retention - Phase 6
This phase relates to the information the brain remembers about the
typeface after the viewing concludes—its last impressions. The information
may consist of all or part of what was discovered or uncovered in
previous phases; or it may actually be innacurate or erroneous impressions.
This phase is crucial if the typeface is to be selected again (say,
for design) based on memory alone.
Subsequent Repeated Viewing
If a familiar typeface is viewed again, phase 1 does not occur. In
fact, the brain my jump to phase 2, then phase 4. It may occasionally
go through phase 5, reinforcing or modifying its experiences, but
it probably never skips phase 6.
It is interesting to observe that once a person develops an opinion
on a particular typeface, the opinion very often never changes. What
is also interesting is that the subliminal impact of a typeface never
changes, and is very often the same for many people, whether or not
their opinion on a particular typeface design is favorable or not.
This is why typeface design and selection is such a compelling factor
in advertising design.
-
back to top
- Fourth sample: MS SANS SERIF, a sans-serif
font.
back to top
- The process whereby a typeface is viewed and its visual characteristics
and impact have an effect on, and are evaluated by, a person. A more
scientific name for this may be «typeface psychology.» The
end purpose of type savoring is not the classification of a typeface,
but, rather, an appraisal of its aesthetic attributes (primary) and
emotional impact (secondary). Type savoring may often be a lengthly
and complex process. It is certainly a very poorly-understood, rarely
studied, and little-discussed aspect of typography. There may be an
extensive set of underlying scientific principles governing type savoring.
Type savoring may reach completion or fruition only after a period
of time and a number of viewings. The process usually proceeds in
a number of phases.
Initial Viewing - Phase 1
The eye and brain evaluates a design for basic stand-alone (macroscopic)
characteristics: type color, ornamentation, stroke contrast, letterform
proportion, letterform design consistency, and possibly other characteristics.
Sometimes, if any of these characteristics are notable, emotional
impact is generated.
Recognition - Phase 2
The eye and brain focus on the individual letterforms, and attempt
to relate their shape (microscopic) characteristics to similar letterforms
(of another typeface perception or mental image). Subliminal impact
of letterform design makes its mark at this stage.
Bargaining - Phase 3
The eye and brain, having evaluated the typeface design both macroscopically
and microscopically, go through an appraisal phase, intermediate between
recognition and comprehension. This could also be termed an « acceptance/
rejection » phase, where the brain, having made comparisons to other
perceived typefaces, attempts to decide (letterform by letterform,
word by word, and overall) whether the design is good or bad, pleasant
or unpleasant, acceptable or unacceptable. This is termed a « bargaining
» phase, because the brain may be performing a trade-off study between
acceptable and rejectable design points. It should be noted that subliminal
and emotional impact is not generated during this phase, but rather
this phase is driven by subliminal and emotional impact uncovered
or generated in previous phases.
Comprehension - Phase 4
The eye and brain then parses the text. If the purpose of the viewing
is type savoring, then this process is merely another test. If a typeface
design presents difficulties in comprehension performance, this is
detected in this phase.
Aftereffects - Phase 5
During or after comprehension, perception and impressions form, stemming
from viewing the typeface design. These impressions may include more
of the subliminal or emotional impact uncovered in previous phases,
along with new impressions. These new impressions may take the form
of subliminal or emotional impact, or concepts, characterized by words
like: attitude, prim, elegance, mechanical, happy, joyful, sad, adamant,
permissive, peculiar, etc.
Retention - Phase 6
This phase relates to the information the brain remembers about the
typeface after the viewing concludes—its last impressions. The information
may consist of all or part of what was discovered or uncovered in
previous phases; or it may actually be innacurate or erroneous impressions.
This phase is crucial if the typeface is to be selected again (say,
for design) based on memory alone.
Subsequent Repeated Viewing
If a familiar typeface is viewed again, phase 1 does not occur. In
fact, the brain my jump to phase 2, then phase 4. It may occasionally
go through phase 5, reinforcing or modifying its experiences, but
it probably never skips phase 6.
It is interesting to observe that once a person develops an opinion
on a particular typeface, the opinion very often never changes. What
is also interesting is that the subliminal impact of a typeface never
changes, and is very often the same for many people, whether or not
their opinion on a particular typeface design is favorable or not.
This is why typeface design and selection is such a compelling factor
in advertising design.
-
back to top |